|
||||
|
OFFICIALS
INCH CLOSER TO A NEW LIBRARY
Members of
Glenview’s village and library boards deadlocked last week over
whether to build a new, 98,000-square-foot facility at a cost of $35
million, rehab and expand the existing downtown building for $25
million or seek a third course of action not proposed by a consultant.
Village
President Kerry Cummings thought
Cummings said
consultant Sente, Rubel, Bosman, Lee had included lots of unnecessary
spaces for computers. She noted that the library’s current collection
of VHS tapes also took up room, but DVDs – which are rapidly replacing
tapes in the media marketplace – were smaller. She questioned the need
for so many magazines on the shelves when copies could be available on
the Internet or on microfiche.
“I see the
answer less in brick and mortar than I do in replacement with modern
collections. I don’t want to skimp on the area for pre-schoolers, and
I don’t want to skimp on some reading areas, but flexibility will be
gained in the future through technology and the way we store our
information. I don’t want to overbuild.”
If the
trustees and library board wanted to spend more than $25 million,
Cummings said she would push for a referendum.
TO VOTE OR
NOT TO VOTE
Library
Trustee Claire McGuire bristled at the mention of a ballot issue.
“Did we go to referendum for the new police station?” she asked.
“No, we did
not,” replied Cummings. “It was not, it was not an increase to the
tax levy, so no impact to the taxpayer, and it was not a $30 million
building.”
“But we got
the $22 million from somewhere,” McGuire replied. “I do not feel we
need to go to referendum for the library, even if it costs $35
million. I think it delays things.” She added that during two public
hearings, residents had clearly demanded a new, world-class library.
Trustee Debby
Karton said only a limited number of people had taken part in those
hearings, while a referendum would give thousands a chance to express
their view “on what we’re doing with their money.”
Library Board
President Arlene Anthony said the community had commissioned reports
from two different consultants. “If we follow their recommendations,
then I think the community will accept the cost. I don’t want to
spend the money on a referendum, and I really don’t think it’s
necessary. The public doesn’t have the time to study this the way we
have, and that’s why they entrusted us with this job.”
She did not
know if a new addition would work well with an existing, rehabbed
structure and felt sure such a library would not be energy efficient.
“I think a lot of this is worrisome and has a lot of costs that would
surprise us,” she said, adding that it might be possible to build a
new structure that would meet community needs for $30 million.
Library Vice
President Jerome McQuie also opposed going to referendum. “A couple
of residents told me: ‘We elected you to the board to make these
decisions. If we’re really pissed off, we’ll call you at three in the
morning.’ My phone number is still listed,” he said.
McQuie shared
Anthony’s doubts about rehabbing. “We could get bitten by this
mid-project. That’s the last thing any of us want.” He warned that
heating and air conditioning the existing building and an addition
could be tricky and costly. If the village could only afford $25
million, McQuie suggested building a large, basic facility, then
adding a parking deck or an annex when more money is available.
“Our
fundamental objective has got to be to create a first-class facility –
a signature building for the downtown,” said Trustee Kimball Woodrow,
chair of
Woodrow, an
investment banker, said he had a fundamental bias toward new
buildings, but he did not rule out rehabbing and building an addition.
“Our firm engages in remodelling projects regularly,” he explained,
“and I’ve seen some extraordinary things done over the years.”
Trustees
Phillip White and Paul Detlefs agreed that a renovated library with an
addition could do the job, but Library Trustee Jack Neymark said an
architect would have a lot more flexibility with a new building.
A
professional accountant, Neymark said families now paying a $5,000 tax
bill would see an increase of $125 per year for a $35 million
building. “I think $125 is a very good value,” he said. “This is
Trustee Pat
Cuisinier and Library trustees Ellen Scholly, David Johnson and David
Winton also voiced enthusiastic support for a new, $35 million
building.
Said Johnson:
“Building a new library is sort of like the farmer going to the feed
store to buy oats. If you want good, clean oats, you gotta’ be
willing to pay a fair price for them. If, on the other hand, you’re
satisfied with oats that have already been through the horse, you can
get a better price.”
The group
chuckled, and Cummings requested a translation.
“No
referendum!” said Johnson.
Editor’s
note:
WHAT’S
NEXT?
Trustee White
wanted more detail about services to be provided in the new library.
He thought Sente, Rubel, Bosman, Lee’s numbers were “excessive.”
White is on the board of the Catholic Theological Seminary, a group
building a 95,000-square-foot structure in
Scholly
pointed out that a theological seminary did not serve the age range
that a public library does, so it was not fair to compare the two.
Anthony
thought the library’s architect – Philips Swager Associates – should
be called in to talk with the two boards about how a building might
function, how the space would be allocated and what actual costs would
be.
White agreed.
“I think we owe it to the community to determine whether renovation is
realistic from a financial standpoint and from a functional
standpoint, and if it isn’t, get it off the table and move on,” he
said.
Village
Manager Todd Hileman suggested further analysis could lead to cost
savings and proposed a new committee be formed to look closely at the
differences between new construction and renovation/expansion.
Cummings said
she would choose a couple of trustees and two village staff members
for the new panel and proposed Anthony appoint two people from her
board and two library staffers.
Hileman
thinks that group might be able to recommend something to both boards
in March or April.
THE
PUBLIC’S PERSPECTIVE
Residents and
business owners were as passionate, articulate and divided as the
trustees in discussing a future library. Here are some of the remarks
offered during a public hearing that preceded the boards’ discussion.
Speaking for
a group called Save Our Library Downtown or “SOLD,” Biff Thiele
noted that since 1997,
A
“We’re
talking about an investment in intellectual and educational
development of our children and citizens in general. I unequivocally
endorse making the maximum investment. A good education pays back
many fold. One other comment I would like to make involves the
gentleman who spoke previously about reduction in the number of visits
to the library. There could be many reasons for that to happen – one
of which is a library that has not kept pace with modern times.”
Ellen
Clark, director of the
Carl
Hanson, a licensed structural engineer:
“I’m in favor of renovating the library, and I
don’t have a problem with expanding it. I consider the existing
library a valuable asset worth at least $10 million. It would be a
waste of money to tear down the beams, walls and foundation, only to
rebuild them again in essentially the same place. If we spend our
money wisely, we can build a magnificent new addition.”
Bud
Boynton, a 50-year resident of
Merton
Silbar, public relations executive: “
Stan Dulkowski, retiree:
“My wife will die if she sees me on TV. When I get up to talk, she
hides under a table. I’ve listened to you people talk about this
thing. I was a blue collar worker. I’ve got two sons. They can’t
afford to live in this town. We’re priced out. You talk about ‘first
class’ this, ‘first class’ that. Look at the police station you’ve
got there. Talk about a legacy for our grandkids! We’re gonna’ give
‘em a big damn tax bill.”
John Ranz,
businessman and fiscal watchdog: “
“We have just
undergone a five- or six-year period of massive building and
development throughout the community, and nowhere do I see any solar
power. I would not like to see what happened in
Richard
Feit, businessman and long-time library watcher:
“Demolition of our 53,000-square-foot granite, steel and concrete
library building that has been declared structurally sound is to waste
$7-10 million in the building value. They renovated in
Microsoft has
contracted to put 100,000 volumes on line from the British Library.
Google has contracted with
Rebecca Gerber, mother and library aide: “A library is not just a place I go to borrow books. It’s a place I go to be with my kids. A library is a great way to encourage kids to read and to get to know other people in the community. It’s a safe place. It’s a good place for the community to meet. We’re not just talking space for books. We’re talking space for meetings, for seniors learning to use computers, for people who don’t speak English as a first language to learn.”
Amy Claver, mother of two: “Last summer they were showing a Winnie the Pooh movie, and I wanted to bring my kids. I was thinking maybe I’ll meet some other parents, as I’m still sort of new to the community. We came, ready to enjoy the movie, but there were tons and tons of people in the hallway, and everybody was scooted in, shoulder to shoulder. The bathrooms are so small, you can’t even change a diaper.”
Norma Morrison, 89 -- Grande
Dame of
PLAN
COMMISSION INCHES TOWARD ISMAILI CENTER APPROVAL
Planners for
a proposed Ismaili Muslim house of worship near the corner of Golf and
Shermer roads presented changes to the plan commission, hoping to
appease neighbors who fear increased traffic, parking problems, light
and noise.
The new plan sets aside land for 50 more parking spaces, bringing the total capacity to 400. It promises improvements to the Golf and Shermer intersection and includes what traffic engineers call a “pork chop’ island at its entry off Shermer to prevent entry from or exit to MacArthur and keep northbound cars on Shermer from making a left-hand turn into the site. (In deference to the dietary laws of Islam, Chairman Howard Silver suggested the traffic guide be called something other than a “pork chop.”)
Finally, the planners said they’d redesigned their lighting and would plant more evergreens to shield the neighbors.
Most members of the commission liked what they heard and said they were not willing to hold up the project over the neighbors’ objections. Still, they were sympathetic. Trustee Steve Bucklin admitted driving through the Park Manor neighborhood is already difficult because of parked cars on the narrow streets. “That’s an issue that has nothing to do with this [Ismaili House of Worship] proposal,” he said, adding that the village should limit parking to one side, add signs to encourage traffic safety and create cul de sacs to stop cut-through traffic.
“Also, I heard over and over about the sidewalks not being plowed. I live on Central, and those sidewalks are plowed every morning when there’s a snowstorm. To have children walking to school [in the street because sidewalks] are not being plowed – is something that I think the village has to look at. That is unacceptable.”
Bucklin did not think the House of Worship would cause flooding, and he warned the neighbors that under current zoning, “we could put office buildings on that property.” He also dismissed concerns about traffic noise, pointing out that the property was close to a couple of very busy streets – Golf and Shermer.
Commissioner Peter Brinckerhoff was prepared to go further. “To approve even one house on this site exacerbates the existing conditions, and I think that has to be solved before we even talk about the house of worship. I know village staff is working on traffic issues and traffic calming devices, and restrictive turning during certain hours. Without those issues being solved, it’s impossible to endorse or allow this to proceed.”
Brinckerhoff pointed out that a “very objective, non-interested third party,” – the Illinois Department of Transportation – had given the intersection of Golf and Shermer a failing grade. “Until I see solutions, I can’t endorse allowing this project to go ahead,” he said.
Commissioner Allan Ruter expressed gratitude to the neighbors for calling their problems to the attention of village leaders and said he regrets that it has taken so long for Village Hall to pay heed. “I’ve run through the neighborhood, and it’s made me a faster runner dodging traffic,” he added, sparking a round of applause.
Chairman Silver said new development should not make matters worse, but he didn’t think it fair to hold the Ismailis responsible for existing traffic problems in Park Manor. “It would not be right to hold this development hostage until the village or the state fixes everything else, but we have to make sure it is not exacerbated by a single car. If we waited for the government to fix everything, nothing would ever get built on that site.”
While one area resident presented petitions from residents who opposed the project (more than 820 people have now signed), some testified that they would welcome the Ismailis.
Bill Zamzow, who lives along the proposed Ismaili property line, recalled the years when Northern Illinois Gas did business from that location. “They had many service trucks and other vehicles parked there. During the morning rush hour, the employees would be arriving, and they would leave during the evening rush hour. Customers would come and pay their gas bills there. The service vehicles were used to respond to emergencies at night and on weekends. I wasn’t aware of any complaints about traffic or noise.”
Michael Weidemann said he had gone to Northlake, where the Ismailis now worship, and talked with seven neighbors. “None of them had any problems with traffic or noise from the Ismaili congregation,” he said. “They were not even aware that morning worship went on, so I can only surmise that there isn’t much of a problem with noise, light or traffic in that neighborhood. Four of them told me that the Ismailis have a couple of people who are magnificent at controlling the traffic and making sure that parking regulations are followed. One man who’s lived across the street from that center for 12 years said it really didn’t make any difference to that neighborhood. He doesn’t notice that they’re there.”
Alice Scott, a 21-year resident
of the Park Manor neighborhood, thought the community might be
“creating a Chicken Little syndrome here with the objections to the
Ismaili House of Worship.” She noted that many parts of
She noted that Ismaili services
are held early in the morning and early in the evening, outside of the
rush hours. “If you’re a commuter, you’re always grateful to be going
against traffic. This institution is doing that for us. If we were
to put a professional building or a bank or some other commercial
enterprise there, we would have people congesting the area when we
want to congest the area. These people are going to come at
Neighbor Ed Campbell demanded to know if the Ismailis actually owned the property. It’s deeded to a company called 100 Shermer Real Estate, LLC. Chairman Silver said the ownership of the property was not an issue, as anyone had the right to request rezoning.
The plan commission will
continue its discussions on the Ismaili House of Worship in January.
The ultimate decision on whether to rezone the property for a
religious center will be made by the village board.
KIRK’S
MISTAKES
Congressman Mark Kirk said he misspoke when he told 400
spectators that
Kirk made the mistake during
a town hall meeting organized to ease the fears of school districts in
Gurnee,
In fact, the feds will
continue to pay
Democratic state Sen. Susan
Garrett of
The Congressman also came
under fire last week for saying he thinks it’s fine to discriminate
against young Muslim men. To protect its borders from foreign
terrorists, Kirk told a conference at
“I’m not threatened by people
from
The leader of a local Muslim civil rights group called the remark “a classic, malicious, bigoted attitude.” “It’s one thing for me to hear it from Joe Schmoe on the street and deal with it as an ignorant attitude and give that person the benefit of the doubt,” said Yaser Tabbara. “It’s another, and 100 times more disturbing and dangerous, to hear something like that spewed out of the mouth of a public figure.” The Chicago Tribune reports a
coalition of 25 groups is now demanding an apology. It includes the
Jewish Council on Urban Affairs; the Archdiocese of Chicago’s Office
of Hispanic Ministry; the
Editor’s note: That
kind of thinking gives militant white men in
LUXEM STEALS MOSQUITO
ABATEMENT SPOTLIGHT With three newly-appointed
members on its board, the controversial North Shore Mosquito Abatement
District met last Saturday. State Rep. Elaine Nekritz and
Member Bill Zimmer caused the
first shock – asking for approval of next year’s $1.3 million budget.
The new members hadn’t even seen the document, and they were not
prepared to vote. Attorney Norm Rosen told them it was just a
formality, since the board will vote again after a 30-day public
comment period. Reassured, the new guys agreed to the spending plan.
The board’s 89-year-old
president Otto Cesario then moved to adjourn, but Luxem wasn’t ready
to go home. He asked if public comment would be permitted. "How much
time will it take?" snapped Cesario. "Two quick minutes," Luxem
replied.
Luxem then began quizzing board
members about their political connections and travels on the public
tab. He wondered if Cesario planned to seek re-election.
“Why are you asking these evil
questions?” Cesario shot back.
Luxem continued. Was it true
that the board’s long-time office manager was stepping down? (Rumor
has it Zimmer’s daughter has been promised the job.)
“No!” said Cesario.
"Yes she is, Otto" said Rosen.
Cesario glared at Luxem. "Who tells you these thing?" he asked. “Meeting adjourned.”
Later, Luxem said he “wanted to
show the three new board members how the real club operated.”
TRAFFIC NEWS AND
NOTES
-- At
-- The Union Pacific railroad line
is installing new concrete pads at the
-- Residents of
VILLAGE BOARD PREVIEW
-- The
trustees will hold a public hearing before discussing a tax hike
during their regular meeting at
-- The board
must also decide whether to extend the contract of downtown consultant
S.B. Friedman to give the firm another $146,718. Village Manager Todd
Hileman says
-- The agenda
and background materials for Tuesday’s meeting are now available
online at
www.glenview.il.us,
although they’re not easy to find, and residents trying to download
over a dial-up line are in for a very long wait. Click on “Board of
Trustees” in the left column, then on “Agendas.”
-- Other
matters to be discussed include service provided by Commonwealth
Edison, a zoning plan for adult bookstores, traffic recommendations
for the complex intersection of Chestnut and Lehigh, and announcement
of a policy for special events at
SAVE
THE DATE
--
The downtown plan committee meets at
--
State
-- North Glen Business and
Professional Women will hold their annual holiday dinner meeting at
READERS
WRITE
NN was
alarmed to hear the trustees may raise taxes to pay for road repairs:
“The village has a nerve even
considering a tax increase. Without the wasteful mismanagement of
funds in general and at The Glen, the village would have plenty of
money for infrastructure in the rest of the town. The last two boards,
novices setting themselves up as developers, spent money like water,
some of it to correct mistakes made through their own ineptness.
Millions were spent on consultants who told them what common sense
should have. Millions more went to corporations demanding incentives
to locate in
NLM thinks
MB resents
JLo’s suggestion that residents in other neighbourhoods be excused
from paying for maintenance at The Glen:
“By that way of thinking, why should The Glen pay for services
in the rest of
Kevin Killion takes us to task over our story about a telephone poll by District 225: “Your item about glowing survey results in the Glenbrook high schools omitted a crucial detail: The survey was commissioned by the district itself, and conducted by Decisions Resources, Ltd. That firm is a hired gun for school districts and municipalities preparing to ask for higher taxes or bond issues. It would be startling if a survey conducted by a company of that kind ever came up with a less than glowing report. For more, see Spinmeisters Come to Town at www.illinoisloop.org/spinmeisters.html.
JV writes about the village board’s refusal to fund taller trees between the new police station and neighbors’ yards: “The police station landscaping is shaping up nicely, but it is interesting that the trustees who were willing to spend $25 million for the police station wasted so much time discussing whether to spend another $50,000 for taller trees.”
Miss K was amused to see
Glenview in the papers this week: “Couldn't help noticing in the
Tribune that the Village Hall and a number of park district
properties, including Wagner Farm, the building the chamber of
commerce is in, and I think Gallery Park, are all scheduled to be sold
in January for non-payment of real estate taxes. What's the story on
that?”
The Watch replies: We
asked
RP is tired of second-class
treatment for his street: “We have
lived on
The Watch replies: Good
news, RP.
AK wonders “whatever happened with plans to hire new human resource and information technology directors at Village Hall?”
The Watch replies:
And on hearing the village manager had terminated former Fire Chief Dan Bonkowski, another reader wrote: “Can he do that? Is there a possibility that the chief will be back?”
The Watch replies: The village manager has full authority to terminate any top staffers without consulting the trustees. Manager Todd Hileman says Chief Dan Bonkowski plans to issue a public statement on his situation later this week.
TW writes about the evolution
of the former EZ Go gas station: “A lot in the 1850 block of
The Watch replies: The
property is owned by a
YOUR TURN: Write to glenviewwatch@aol.com or 3537 Maple Leaf Drive, Glenview, IL 60026. If you haven’t already done so, please consider making a contribution to support The Watch. Non-deductible checks should be payable to Glenview Watch. Thanks for your support and for reading. Dean Schott and Sandy Hausman, Co-Editors.
|
||||